01 · Learn the idea
Define the decision before calculating
A fictional community group needs 400 single-sided flyers and has $34 for printing. Supplier A charges $12 setup plus $0.05 per flyer; supplier B charges $3 setup plus $0.08 per flyer. Both can meet the deadline, and there are no other fees in this model. Choose a supplier and justify affordability, not just the smaller per-flyer rate.
Let n be a nonnegative whole number of flyers. Write A(n)=12+0.05n and B(n)=3+0.08n. Make a table at 0,100,300,400,500. Create a simple paper flyer mockup and a diagram showing how a setup cost and repeated unit costs make a total. Explain why algebra helps find an exact crossover while a graph helps communicate the comparison.
02 · Build understanding
Solve, interpret, and challenge
Set 12+0.05n=3+0.08n to find n=300, where both cost $27. At 400, A costs $32 and B costs $35, so only A fits the $34 budget. For n below 300, B is cheaper; above 300, A is cheaper under the stated assumptions.
Solve each budget inequality. A can supply at most 440 flyers for $34; B at most 387 whole flyers because (34−3)/0.08=387.5. Rounding up would exceed the budget. Estimate costs mentally before checking with a calculator or spreadsheet.
03 · Build understanding
Revise the plan with a new requirement
Now the group needs 450 flyers. Under the same $34 budget, A costs $34.50 and B $39, so neither fits. Present options such as increasing the budget by $0.50, reducing the quantity if acceptable, or obtaining a new quote. Do not claim the original plan still works after its requirement changes.
Write a recommendation with assumptions, equations, table, graph, diagram, and checks. Present it to a partner who challenges one assumption; if working independently, write and answer a plausible challenge. Evaluate whether the tool choices and representations helped explain the decision.
04 · Build understanding
Worked example: team shirts, from question to defended answer
A school band needs 35 team shirts and has $320. Shop A charges a $60 design fee plus $7 per shirt. Shop B charges a $20 design fee plus $9 per shirt. Which shop should the band choose?
Step 1: Analyze the information. The decision depends on the total cost for 35 shirts at each shop and on the $320 limit. The fee and the price per shirt both matter.
Step 2: Make a plan. Write a cost function for each shop, evaluate both at 35, and compare each total with the budget. A(n) = 60 + 7n and B(n) = 20 + 9n, where n is the number of shirts.
Step 3: Find the solution. A(35) = 60 + 245 = 305 dollars and B(35) = 20 + 315 = 335 dollars. Only Shop A is within $320.
Step 4: Justify it. Set 60 + 7n = 20 + 9n. Subtract 7n and 20 to get 40 = 2n, so n = 20, where both shops charge $200. After that, each extra shirt adds $7 at Shop A and $9 at Shop B, so Shop A is cheaper for more than 20 shirts. 35 is more than 20, so the two results agree.
Step 5: Judge the reasonableness. Solving 60 + 7n ≤ 320 gives n ≤ 37.14..., so Shop A covers at most 37 shirts: 37 shirts cost $319 and 38 cost $326. The band needs 35, which is under that limit, so the answer makes sense.
05 · Build understanding
Worked example: test a claim before you accept it
A water tank holds 180 gallons and drains at 12 gallons per minute. A classmate says the tank will still be draining after 20 minutes. Decide whether the claim is reasonable.
Step 1: Write a model so the claim can be tested. The volume after t minutes is V(t) = 180 − 12t gallons.
Step 2: Find when the tank is empty, because the model stops making sense after that. Solve 180 − 12t = 0 to get t = 15 minutes.
Step 3: Test the claim in the model. V(20) = 180 − 240 = −60. A tank cannot hold −60 gallons, so the claim is not reasonable.
Step 4: State the limits of the model. It describes the tank only for 0 ≤ t ≤ 15. The graph shows the model as a solid line that stops at (15, 0). The dashed part past it, down to the open point (20, −60), is where the formula keeps going but the tank does not.
Step 5: Communicate the result in one precise sentence: the tank is empty after 15 minutes, because 12 gallons per minute for 15 minutes removes all 180 gallons.
06 · Build understanding
Match the tool and the representation to the job
Mental math and estimation are for quick checks. For the band, round 35 shirts up to 40: 40 × 7 = 280 dollars, and the $60 fee brings the total to about $340. The real cost has to be a little under that, so a calculator answer of $305 is believable and an answer of $3,050 is not.
A table organizes several cases at once. For the two shops, n: 10, 20, 30, 40 gives A: 130, 200, 270, 340 and B: 110, 200, 290, 380. You can see Shop B is cheaper at 10 shirts, the shops tie at 20, and Shop A is cheaper after that.
An equation gives the exact crossover, which a table or a hand-drawn graph might only show roughly. A graph is the best way to show the whole comparison to other people. The graph here shows two lines that cross at (20, 200), with Shop B starting lower on the vertical axis at 20 and rising more steeply.
A spreadsheet or graphing calculator is worth the setup time when there are many cases or awkward decimals. For one or two values, paper and pencil is faster.
- Shop A
- Shop B
07 · Build understanding
Three mistakes to watch for
Comparing only one number. Shop A has the lower price per shirt and Shop B has the lower fee. Neither fact decides the question alone. At 10 shirts Shop B costs $110 and Shop A costs $130, and at 35 shirts the order is reversed.
Rounding a budget limit up. The limit of 37.14... shirts rounds down to 37. Rounding to 38 gives a cost of $326, which is $6 over the $320 the band has.
Giving a conclusion with no numbers. "Shop A is better" cannot be checked. "Shop A costs $305 for 35 shirts, which is $30 less than Shop B and $15 under the budget" can be checked by anyone who reads it.
Apply and explain
Your turn
Produce and defend the complete 400-flyer plan, including both budget limits and crossover. Then revise it for 450 flyers. Submit the mockup/diagram, table, graph, equations, exact checks, and written or oral argument, with a response to a challenge.
Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.
Check your reasoning
A is the feasible choice at 400: $32 versus $35. Crossover is 300 at $27. Budget maxima are 440 and 387 whole flyers. At 450, neither is feasible; A requires $0.50 more. A complete solution ties rates and intercepts to the decision and evaluates the changed assumptions.
- All requirements and assumptions identified
- Tools and estimates justified
- Representations agree and show whole-count restrictions
- Recommendation checked and revised
- Precise argument answers a challenge
Ready to practice?
Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.
Defend a printing plan practice →