Learn · Algebra I

Defend a printing plan

Use a complete problem-solving cycle with multiple representations.

Original curriculum. These lessons and questions have not been independently reviewed.

01 · Learn the idea

Define the decision before calculating

A fictional community group needs 400 single-sided flyers and has $34 for printing. Supplier A charges $12 setup plus $0.05 per flyer; supplier B charges $3 setup plus $0.08 per flyer. Both can meet the deadline, and there are no other fees in this model. Choose a supplier and justify affordability, not just the smaller per-flyer rate.

Let n be a nonnegative whole number of flyers. Write A(n)=12+0.05n and B(n)=3+0.08n. Make a table at 0,100,300,400,500. Create a simple paper flyer mockup and a diagram showing how a setup cost and repeated unit costs make a total. Explain why algebra helps find an exact crossover while a graph helps communicate the comparison.

02 · Build understanding

Solve, interpret, and challenge

Set 12+0.05n=3+0.08n to find n=300, where both cost $27. At 400, A costs $32 and B costs $35, so only A fits the $34 budget. For n below 300, B is cheaper; above 300, A is cheaper under the stated assumptions.

Solve each budget inequality. A can supply at most 440 flyers for $34; B at most 387 whole flyers because (34−3)/0.08=387.5. Rounding up would exceed the budget. Estimate costs mentally before checking with a calculator or spreadsheet.

03 · Build understanding

Revise the plan with a new requirement

Now the group needs 450 flyers. Under the same $34 budget, A costs $34.50 and B $39, so neither fits. Present options such as increasing the budget by $0.50, reducing the quantity if acceptable, or obtaining a new quote. Do not claim the original plan still works after its requirement changes.

Write a recommendation with assumptions, equations, table, graph, diagram, and checks. Present it to a partner who challenges one assumption; if working independently, write and answer a plausible challenge. Evaluate whether the tool choices and representations helped explain the decision.

04 · Build understanding

Worked example: team shirts, from question to defended answer

A school band needs 35 team shirts and has $320. Shop A charges a $60 design fee plus $7 per shirt. Shop B charges a $20 design fee plus $9 per shirt. Which shop should the band choose?

Step 1: Analyze the information. The decision depends on the total cost for 35 shirts at each shop and on the $320 limit. The fee and the price per shirt both matter.

Step 2: Make a plan. Write a cost function for each shop, evaluate both at 35, and compare each total with the budget. A(n) = 60 + 7n and B(n) = 20 + 9n, where n is the number of shirts.

Step 3: Find the solution. A(35) = 60 + 245 = 305 dollars and B(35) = 20 + 315 = 335 dollars. Only Shop A is within $320.

Step 4: Justify it. Set 60 + 7n = 20 + 9n. Subtract 7n and 20 to get 40 = 2n, so n = 20, where both shops charge $200. After that, each extra shirt adds $7 at Shop A and $9 at Shop B, so Shop A is cheaper for more than 20 shirts. 35 is more than 20, so the two results agree.

Step 5: Judge the reasonableness. Solving 60 + 7n ≤ 320 gives n ≤ 37.14..., so Shop A covers at most 37 shirts: 37 shirts cost $319 and 38 cost $326. The band needs 35, which is under that limit, so the answer makes sense.

05 · Build understanding

Worked example: test a claim before you accept it

A water tank holds 180 gallons and drains at 12 gallons per minute. A classmate says the tank will still be draining after 20 minutes. Decide whether the claim is reasonable.

Step 1: Write a model so the claim can be tested. The volume after t minutes is V(t) = 180 − 12t gallons.

Step 2: Find when the tank is empty, because the model stops making sense after that. Solve 180 − 12t = 0 to get t = 15 minutes.

Step 3: Test the claim in the model. V(20) = 180 − 240 = −60. A tank cannot hold −60 gallons, so the claim is not reasonable.

Step 4: State the limits of the model. It describes the tank only for 0 ≤ t ≤ 15. The graph shows the model as a solid line that stops at (15, 0). The dashed part past it, down to the open point (20, −60), is where the formula keeps going but the tank does not.

Step 5: Communicate the result in one precise sentence: the tank is empty after 15 minutes, because 12 gallons per minute for 15 minutes removes all 180 gallons.

(0, 180)(15, 0)(20, −60)
The tank line falls from (0, 180) to (15, 0) and stops. The dashed part beyond it, down to the open point (20, −60), is not part of the model.

06 · Build understanding

Match the tool and the representation to the job

Mental math and estimation are for quick checks. For the band, round 35 shirts up to 40: 40 × 7 = 280 dollars, and the $60 fee brings the total to about $340. The real cost has to be a little under that, so a calculator answer of $305 is believable and an answer of $3,050 is not.

A table organizes several cases at once. For the two shops, n: 10, 20, 30, 40 gives A: 130, 200, 270, 340 and B: 110, 200, 290, 380. You can see Shop B is cheaper at 10 shirts, the shops tie at 20, and Shop A is cheaper after that.

An equation gives the exact crossover, which a table or a hand-drawn graph might only show roughly. A graph is the best way to show the whole comparison to other people. The graph here shows two lines that cross at (20, 200), with Shop B starting lower on the vertical axis at 20 and rising more steeply.

A spreadsheet or graphing calculator is worth the setup time when there are many cases or awkward decimals. For one or two values, paper and pencil is faster.

(0, 60)(0, 20)(20, 200)
  • Shop A
  • Shop B
Shop A starts at (0, 60) and Shop B starts lower, at (0, 20). The lines cross at (20, 200), and Shop B is higher after that.

07 · Build understanding

Three mistakes to watch for

Comparing only one number. Shop A has the lower price per shirt and Shop B has the lower fee. Neither fact decides the question alone. At 10 shirts Shop B costs $110 and Shop A costs $130, and at 35 shirts the order is reversed.

Rounding a budget limit up. The limit of 37.14... shirts rounds down to 37. Rounding to 38 gives a cost of $326, which is $6 over the $320 the band has.

Giving a conclusion with no numbers. "Shop A is better" cannot be checked. "Shop A costs $305 for 35 shirts, which is $30 less than Shop B and $15 under the budget" can be checked by anyone who reads it.

Apply and explain

Your turn

Produce and defend the complete 400-flyer plan, including both budget limits and crossover. Then revise it for 450 flyers. Submit the mockup/diagram, table, graph, equations, exact checks, and written or oral argument, with a response to a challenge.

Use paper or explain your thinking aloud before opening the solution.

Check your reasoning

A is the feasible choice at 400: $32 versus $35. Crossover is 300 at $27. Budget maxima are 440 and 387 whole flyers. At 450, neither is feasible; A requires $0.50 more. A complete solution ties rates and intercepts to the decision and evaluates the changed assumptions.

  • All requirements and assumptions identified
  • Tools and estimates justified
  • Representations agree and show whole-count restrictions
  • Recommendation checked and revised
  • Precise argument answers a challenge

Ready to practice?

Try the questions, get feedback, and review your reasoning.

Defend a printing plan practice →